|
LETTER XIV.
"Even the declarations made by themselves, seem wholly new and strange to them; they forget not only what they have
seen, but what they have said." Wilberforce, on the Slave Trade. 18th April, 1791.1
LONDON, 23d Dec. 1793.
My dear Madam,
I concluded my last by telling you Mr.----- [DuBois] had some business to settle with the Directors, part of which was
on account of what they were, and yet are, indebted to me as the widow of Mr. Falconbridge, for money left in their hands,
and for salary due to him when he died.
Six months earlier John Clarkson had written in a letter to Isaac DuBois (dated 1 July 1793) that Alexander Falconbridge
had made a will before he left for Sierra Leone, and that the Company 'had money of his in their Hands'. The will was in the
custody of Richard Phillips, the lawyer who had helped Falconbridge with his book. Although that money should go to Anna Maria
after her husband’s death, Clarkson warned DuBois that 'the Company are now so very, very frugal that I should not wonder
if they hesitated paying the money as they all exclaim against Falconbridge and say he has deceived them so much, and run
them to such immense expenses'. 2
About a week after we came to town, I called at Mr. Henry Thornton's, but not finding him at home, left my address with
a message, that I wished to see him on business. Several days elapsed without a syllable from Mr. Thornton, and conjecturing
the servant might have omitted delivering either my card or message, I called again, when his house-keeper assured me he had
received both, but was then at his country seat at Clapham; I now left a note mentioning the circumstance of having waited
on him twice, and beg[g]ing to be acquainted when I could have the pleasure of seeing him; four or five days more passed away
without any answer, which puzzled me very much to account for. Unwilling, however, to nurse any suspicion that either insult
or injury could possibly be intended me by a man who had spontaneously made such declarations of friendship as Mr. Thornton
did to me before I went last to Africa, and whose character is currently reported to possess as little alloy as frail man
can be charged with, I therefore determined to venture another letter before I formed any opinion. The consequence of this
was an answer that staggered me a vast deal more than his silence; he informed me I would find him at his banking house in
Bartholomew lane from ten to twelve the following day, if I chose to call there. I was vexed at receiving so
affronting a note from Mr. Thornton because it gave me room to question his veracity and the Directors good intentions towards
me; nevertheless, a consciousness of having done nothing to merit such rudeness, and my interest requiring me to see him,
I curbed my nettled pride, collected as much composure as it was possible, and met the gentleman on his own ground. I believe
he neither expected or wished for this meeting; when I entered his counting room, he blushed confusion and with some difficulty
stammered out, "Pray, madam, what is your business with me?"
"I have been induced to take so much pains to see you, Sir, to request you will get the Directors to settle Mr. Falconbridge's
accounts and pay what is owing me," answered I.
"Why," said he, "Mr. Falconbridge kept no books, and he appears to be considerably in debt to the Company."
"Kept no books, Sir, how can that be when I have a copy of them this moment in my hands, a duplicate of which I know your
Accountant at Sierra Leone (in whose possession the original books are) has sent the Directors."
"I have never seen them; pray what is the amount of your demand?" replied Mr. Thornton. I then produced an abstract account
stating the sum.
"Why," says he, "it’s a large amount; I did not know Mr. Falconbridge left any money in our hands. I thought he had
received it; and his accounts for the Lapwing's first voyage were never settled."
This language startled me a good deal, but I refreshed his memory regarding the money left with the Directors and told
him he also laboured under a mistake respecting the Lapwing's accounts, for he must recollect they were settled, and
that he, fortunately, paid the balance of £74. 19s. 6d. to myself.
Naked truths thus staring him in the face, made him at a loss what to say; however, after a little reflection, he told
me, "Whatever is due to you, madam, must be paid; if you will walk into another room and wait a few moments, I will send for
Mr. Williams, the Secretary, who will see every thing set right."
I was then shewn into a large cold room covered with painted floor cloth, where, after waiting some time half frozed, Mr.
Williams came. His behaviour was gentlemanlike. When I had recapitulated nearly what I said to Mr. Thornton, he enquired if
Mr. Falconbridge left a will in my favour? which having answered in the affirmative, he wished me joy, as it would prevent
others from sharing of the little property he left—desired me to get the will proved, and when that was done there would
be no impediment whatever in my way, and I should be paid immediately.
In a few days after, Mr.----- [DuBois] saw Mr. Williams, who told him he had better omit proving the will till the Court
exactly ascertained what amount I had to receive, as it would save expence. Perhaps Mr. Williams intended a kindness by this
admonition, for he must have known then, what I am now sure of, that the Directors mean, if they possibly can, to withhold
every sixpence from me. At least there is great reason to suppose so from their quibbling conduct.
After detaining us here all this time, and shuffling Mr.----- [DuBois] off from one Court to another, without assigning any honest, business like reason for doing so; they now wind up their
prevarications, by saying they must wait for further information from Sierra Leone, which I look upon tantamount to a positive
refusal. Indeed, it would have been much handsomer had they candidly declared at once that it was not their intention to pay
me—for their evasive answers have increased the injury by prolonging our stay here to the overthrow of some plans Mr.----
[DuBois] had in contemplation.
What do you think of their charging me with the presents they particularly directed I should purchase for, and make, Queen
Naimbana; with the stores granted by the Court for me to take to Sierra Leone, my journey to Bristol and Falmouth, and every
little donation they made, either to Mr. Falconbridge, or myself?
But besides these paltry, pitiful charges, they bring forward three others of much greater consequence, though founded
on equally shameful and frivolous grounds, viz. the Lapwing's cargo with all the expences of her first voyage and for
eight months before she left the river Thames;—the goods sent in the Duke of Buccleugh, together with the freight
and passage money paid Messrs. Anderson's, and the Amy's cargo when we last went to Africa.
They might with as much propriety have included the whole of the Company's funds that have been thrown away;—yes,
shamefully so,—no set of raw boys just let loose from school could have disposed of them more injudiciously. What had
Mr. Falconbridge to do with the disbursement of the Lapwing? Her master was the ostensible person. The trifling goods
sent out in her and the Duke of Buccleugh were all appropriated conformable to the instructions Mr. Falconbridge received;
they were not intended for trading with, but merely as gifts of charity and bribes to pacify the covetous natives. Therefore,
if Mr. Falconbridge had not accounted for them, it would be very easy to find out whether they had been disposed of that way.
But I know every thing was settled previous to our second voyage, and it is only a poor, mean finesse in the Directors to
say otherwise.
As to the Amy's cargo, true—it was consigned to Mr. Falconbridge; but that consignment was done away when
he received his fresh instructions after we arrived at Sierra Leone; and before that vessel left Africa, the Master of her
got a receipt for his whole cargo from the Governor and Council, which receipt the Directors have at this moment. 3
I will not interrupt your time with this subject longer than to give you the sentiments of the late Governor of Sierra
Leone, who says in a letter of the 15th instant to Mr.----- [ DuBois], "I am sorry the Directors should give you so much trouble and particularly about the cargo of the Lapwing for
her first voyage. They certainly are unacquainted with the circumstances and the situation of Falconbridge on his first voyage,
or they would never be so minute, particularly with his widow, who experienced such unheard of hardships.
"I hope I speak truth when I pronounce their late Commercial Agent an honest man, but a very unfortunate one, not in the
least calculated for the station he filled, which men of discernment might have discovered at first view. I assure you, had
I been on board the Lapwing on her first voyage by myself in Sierra Leone river without a person in the neighbourhood
likely to befriend me (which was the case with Falconbridge), knowing the country as I do, I should have thought myself extremely
happy to have returned safe to my native country, without any cargo at all."
Anna Maria is so furious with Henry Thornton that she decides to make her situation public, regardless of any effect it
may have on the Sierra Leone Company or the settlement in Freetown. She is not as magnanimous as John Clarkson, who has written
DuBois that he will not take any action to protest his dismissal. He dares not do anything that will bring public discredit
on the Colony, for it has many enemies in England who would rejoice at having an opportunity of prejudicing the minds of the
subscribers against it. Their cavalier treatment of John Clarkson adds further fuel to Anna Maria’s fury with the Director’s
attitude toward her.
I shall now leave you to make what comments you please on the vexatious treatment I have received from those Gentlemen,
and to turn in your mind what my prospects would have been had I come home implicitly confiding in the profusion of friendly
promises they bestowed on me (unsought for) when last in England.
I certainly had a right to build some expectations from them; but in place of any, you find those paragons of virtue
and human excellence unwilling to do me common justice, refusing to pay me what is religiously my right—a little
pittance, which God knows I gave the highest price for!
However, if there is any comfort in having company in one's misfortunes or ill usage, I have that satisfaction. Their treatment
to Mr. Clarkson (the late Governor) and others has been highly discreditable, but their behaviour to the two Deputies from
Sierra Leone and consequently to all their constituents is the most inconsistent part of their conduct because any injury
done them must annoy and jar the Company's interest.
(At this point Anna Maria inserts a lengthy reiteration of the grievances of the black settlers in Freetown and their representatives
who have come to London to protest to the Sierra Leone Company Board of Directors. Because this segment interrupts the flow
of her narrative, it has been eliminated.)
When Isaac DuBois is dismissed by the Sierra Leone Company directors, Anna Maria has reached the point where further protest
seems pointless. She will complete her documentation of her two voyages to Sierra Leone for publication and be done with it.
The public does not need to know any more about her personal life.
When John Clarkson hears of DuBois’s dismissal, he writes Thornton in dismay: "With respect to DuBois I am to [sic]
much hurt to say anything about him—his behaviour was so exemplary, his Manners so engaging, and his zeal and industry
to promote the Happiness and Comfort of the Colony so conspicuous that I assure you I attribute the first foundation of the
Colony in great part to him." 4
To DuBois, who writes asking him for a character reference, Clarkson replies, "Truth obliges me to say, that I attribute
the commencement of regularity, order and the comfort of the Colony, principally to your exertions, and your readiness to
comply with every request of mine for the good of the Company with respect and cheerfulness. I must also thank you for your
kind and humane treatment of those committed to your care, and the great allowances you made for their Situation, as well
as for your firmness in enforcing a just and proper behaviour of the People towards the Company. All this I informed the Directors
upon my arrival in England." 5
And in a letter to a friend in Nova Scotia Clarkson writes, "the Government there has induced a man to resign whom I can
justly say has done more good in the Colony than all the rest put together, but he happened to have rather a more enlarged
Mind than his Superiors and would not brook their behaviour to him ... . I fear altho' I mentioned him so handsomely upon
my arrival and specified the numerous works he had undertaken and completed, yet they will not listen to any thing he may
have to say to vindicate his behaviour in quitting the Colony. The Nova Scotians were doatingly fond of him, he kept them
at a proper distance, behaved kind to them and made them do their duty. Besides he was known to many of them when they were
slaves in America." 6
Thornton ignores all of Clarkson’s protests. He intends to couple DuBois with Falconbridge as scapegoats for the
Colony's early misfortunes. 7
* * *
Anna Maria writes one more letter:
To HENRY THORNTON, Esq. M. P. and Chairman
of the Court of Directors of the Sierra Leone Company, &c. &c.
King's Arms Yard, Coleman-street, London.
BRISTOL, April 4, 1794.
SIR,
Being earnestly solicited by several friends to publish the History of my Two Voyages to Africa, and having with
some reluctance consented, I feel it incumbent on me to address this letter to you (which is hereafter intended for publication)
by way of acquiting a tribute truth and candor demands, in support of what I have, necessarily, mentioned regarding the Directors
behaviour to me.
It is needless, Sir, to take a more distant retrospect of the subject matter than to the time of our arrival from Sierra
Leone in 1791. If you will turn over to that period and search into your personal behaviour, as well as the Court of
Directors, to Mr. Falconbridge, I am persuaded you will find it marked with repeated testimonies of approbation and applause
for the services you were pleased to say he had rendered the common interest and original views of the Company.
For what purpose did the Directors vote us a compensation for our losses? Or for what purpose did they remove Mr. Falconbridge
out of his particular province as a medical man and make him their Commercial Agent?
Were these not tokens of satisfaction and rewards for his extraordinary exertions to serve the Company; or were they mere
tricks of chicane and deception to inveigle him to return to Africa and answer the desirable end of securing a footing for
the Emigrants, then expected from America? Let your own heart, Sir, decide upon these questions.
I understand the Directors persist to say [that] Mr. Falconbridge had not settled the accounts of his first voyage before
he left England the second time; and that they impeach his memory by saying he has not accounted for the cargo of the Amy,
consigned to him as Commercial Agent. Is it so, Sir? Are these the paltry subterfuges made use of for withholding the poor
pittance I am entitled to? If they are, I shall charitably suppose, for a moment, they proceed from error, and endeavour once
more to set you right,—though, believe me, [with] not with the smallest expectation of profiting thereby.
To the first I shall observe: You must labor under the misfortune of a very careless memory if you cannot recollect that
all Mr. Falconbridge's accounts, anteceding the 25th of December, 1791, were adjusted to that time, and that I received from
yourself a balance of £74. 19s. 6d., which appeared on the face of the account in his favor.
Can you deny the truth of this assertion and say there was no such settlement? If you can, I will not attribute it to any
harsher cause than bad memory, for I yet think it is impossible, Mr. Thornton would be so pitiful, willingly, to utter
an untruth.
But if this pointed circumstance had not happened and I was wholly ignorant of the affair, I should suppose men of business
(as some of the Directors must be) would never have suffered him, or any person else, to commence the transactions of a new
concern 'till those of the old were clearly concluded, but more especially so in this instance, as the charities Mr. Falconbridge
had the distribution of on his first voyage were the property of the St. George's Bay Company, whose original funds and effects
were taken in account by the Sierra Leone Company upon their incorporation, and therefore it was certainly necessary that
the Directors should be made acquainted with the true state of their affairs.
To the second, I have to remind you that Mr. Falconbridge never received the Cargo of the Amy and consequently cannot
account for what he was not in possession of. Upon his arrival in Africa he got instructions from the Directors placing him
entirely under the control of the Superintendant and Council, and the property of the Company solely under their direction.
Consequently the first consignment and unlimited instructions given him became nugatory. Furthermore, the master of the Amy
got a receipt for his whole Cargo from the Governor and Council previous to his leaving Sierra Leone, which is just now in
possession of the Directors.
Mr. Falconbridge had no independent authority or management over the company's goods after he received those instructions,
nor did he give any orders of himself, as other hair-brained members of council did, but got written instructions from the
Superintendant and Council for every sixpence worth he had, either from ship-board or else where, all of which is accounted
for in his books, delivered Mr. Grey by the particular desire of Mr. Dawes. 8
I am inclined to believe the Directors are already acquainted with these circumstances;. indeed it is almost impossible
they can be ignorant of them. But admitting they are, what excuse can they have for swelling up an account against me with
fictitious niggardly charges such as charging me with disbursements for the Lapwing's first voyage, not only during
her voyage, but for six or seven months before she left the river Thames? The freight and passage money of the Duke of
Buccleugh paid Messrs. Anderson? The presents I was desired to purchase and make Queen Naimbana, for which I have your
letter as authority? The stores I was allowed to take with me for our use at Sierra Leone? Our journey to Bristol, Falmouth,
&c. &c.?
How can your Honorable Court, formed as it is of Members of Parliament, Bankers, and some of the first Merchants
in the City of London, all professing the quintessence of philanthropy, thus depreciate its worth by being guilty of such
gross meanness? I verily believe it would be impossible to cull from the Migratory Chapmen of Rag Fair, any number
of men who would not blush to be detected in a similar transaction. 9
That the Directors had cause to be displeased with Mr. Falconbridge for not extending their commercial views may be in
some measure true; but tied up as he was to obey the dictates of the Superintendant and Council, who would not listen to any
arrangements of the kind until comfort and regularity were established in the Colony—What was he to do? However if he
was altogether in fault, was he not punished by annulling his appointment as Commercial Agent? Could the Directors do more?
If they had blindly (as they certainly did in many instances) made improper appointments, what more could they do than annul
them when they discovered their mistake?
But I should suppose it did not require any great discernment to know that a Surgeon, unacquainted with mercantile affairs,
would make but as poor a figure in that line as a Merchant, who had not studied physic or anatomy, would make in the practice
of surgery.
Mr. Falconbridge's dismission did not charge or accuse him with any crime but wanting knowledge of his business;
and what information the Directors could get on that score must have been from a quarter as ignorant, if not more so than
himself;—but surely it was their province to have convinced themselves, when they made the appointment, whether he was
equal to it or not.
Did not Mr Falconbridge's dismission stipulate that his salary was to continue till the Governor and Council procured him
a passage to England? Could there have been the smallest idea at that time of detaining either the money left in the hands
of the Directors, or his wages? Surely not. Then why do the Directors now (he is no more) withhold payment from me?
For shame, Mr. THORNTON, for shame!!! How can you wink at my being so shabbily treated after the unexampled sufferings
I have undergone, and after the prodigality of fair promises I had from you to induce me to return a second time to Africa.
Did you not tell me [that] if any accident befell Falconbridge, I should be handsomely provided for by the Company? Surely
you cannot forget making such a promise;—which you not only forego fulfilling, but shamefully keep back (all I require
of you) the trifling sum so justly due to me.
If the Directors were not fearful of subjecting their conduct (towards me) to the investigation of impartial men, they
never would have refused submitting the affair to arbitration, as was offered; nor would they have threatened or boasted that
they would ruin me with an expensive law-suit in Chancery when I signified my intention of trying the cause at Common Law,
if they meant to do the fair thing.
I cannot help forming those conjectures, for how are we to calculate the principles of men but by their actions? Though,
believe me, Mr. Thornton, notwithstanding all I have said of the Court of Directors, I yet firmly believe [that] if the decision
was left wholly to yourself, I should have ample justice, and I cannot avoid thinking, from the opinion I have heretofore
formed of your benevolence of heart, that you are secretly ashamed of the Directors nefarious treatment to me.
I will not trespass on your time any longer, but shall quit the subject, with referring my cause to the loftiest of Tribunals,
where reigns a judge of mercy, vengeance, and justice, who, I am persuaded, will not let such turpitude go unpunished, and
who has probably already began to shew his displeasure.
Pray, Sir, receive this letter with temper and consider it comes from a Woman aggravated by insults and injury.
I am, &c. &c.
ANNA MARIA --------
FINIS.
APPENDIX. 10
In the Preface, the Public is referred to the Directors of the Sierra Leone Company for the authenticity of the Author's
assertions, who now thinks proper as a further vindication to annex the following letter, which speaks for itself.
Moreover, she avails herself of this supplement to express her vexation at the number of typographical errors throughout
the foregoing pages; besides those enumerated, she has discovered several others, such as, Preface, allmost for almost;
page 35, spinnage, for spinage; page 80, maddern for madder; page 176, least for last—and one or
two more which she hopes the reader has mercifully looked over and not charged to her pen.
* * *
To Henry Thornton, Esq., M.P. and Chairman of the Court of Directors of
the Sierra Leone Company.
Bristol, August 11, 1794.
SIR,
Your not answering my last letter, and the disdain you have shewn me on other occasions since I came last to England, has
not deterred me from doing what I considered honorable and upright.
Conscience, never wandering Monitor, advised me I should fall short of that sincerity I boast to possess and proudly nourish
if I omitted sending you a copy of my Voyages to Africa before they were presented to the World.
This admonition (which no doubt grew from a desire "to hide the fault I see," 11
and a persuasion of having adhered most scrupulously to truth) prompted me to present a Copy to that valuable and ever to
be esteemed Divine Mr. GILBERT, who will give the same to you for your perusal, immediately on his arrival in London, for
which place he sets off this morning.
Would to God! you may read with calmness! but I fear a prepossession of the Author's obscurity and insignificance will
betray you; nay, I already anticipate your reproachful smiles at my mean diction and trite remarks, but remember, Sir, Truth,
though unadorned, never fails to attract notice—it carries its own value—always shelters the innocent,and brands
conviction on the malefactor's threshold.
Search the secret recesses of your bosom and enquire if the Directors conduct to me has not been a violation of those fundamental
principles which should govern the actions of every man or body of men? Yes, Sir, ask there if I am not an injured
Woman?
Remember for a moment my little patrimony has been expended in your service. Remember my matchless sufferings;—and
remember likewise your own honour and credit. I say, remember these things, and they may point out what you ought to do.
The second document of Christianity is to make contrition for our offences. All, from the Palace to the Cottage,
are liable to err, and none of us should blush to confess our penitence; however, let the impulse of your own heart guide
you. What I have done exonerates mine.
I am, Sir, Your obedient Servant,
ANNA MARIA -----------.
Anna Maria would have laid down her quill and muttered, "So there." She would like to stomp into Henry Thornton’s
solemn banking house, stride into the inner sanctum where he rules from a gilded chair far above all the ordinary citizens
in the public rooms, and thumb her nose at Henry Thornton.
But it would be futile. Thornton, by accident of birth and position, has it in his power to withhold from her the trifling
funds that her late husband would have passed on to her. She can do little about it save make her grievances public. Even
then, Thornton is probably immune to embarrassment, confident no one will pay any attention to her ranting.
She thinks of her patient Isaac, going from committee to commission to court, trying to pry his own inheritance out of
the legal system. He will probably be shafted too. The patrimony worth £30,000 abandoned in North Carolina during the war
will doubtless be translated by the Compensation Board into a far more meager sum. 12
Their attitude: Take it, and be glad you get anything at all.
Never mind. Anna Maria exults in the fact that she and Isaac are both young, both handsome, both energetic. The conjugal
relations are delicious (she fears she is enjoying them far more than a proper lady should), and they like each other out
of bed as well. They may have to pinch pennies, but when she remembers the vicissitudes of her first marriage, Anna Maria
believes that with Isaac her prospects for future happiness are so felicitous that her heart sings.
In 1802, when Anna Maria’s journal was printed for the second time, how many people did she hope to reach with her
Narrative of Two Voyages to the River Sierra Leone? A thousand? Five thousand? Ten thousand? Surely no more than that.
Yet two hundred years later three writers, one in Australia, 13 another in England,14 and a third in Virginia have been so entranced with her narrative that they sat down at their desks to
bring her tale to the attention of many hundreds more. Could she but have known.
Endnotes:
1. From 'Debate on Mr. Wilberforce's Motion for the Abolition
of the Slave Trade, 1791', in Hansard, The Parliamentary History of England from the Earliest
Period to the Year 1803 (London: T. C. Hansard, 1817), vol. 29,
p. 256. Coleman, p. 167.
Fyfe, Anna Maria Falconbridge, p. 139. "Here she boldly turns the tables on Wilberforce, a director
of the Sierra Leone Company, by quoting back at him from his historic speech in the House of Commons in which he introduced
the first motion for the abolition of the slave trade, his own ironic strictures on those who defended it."
2. British Library, Clarkson Papers, MS Add. 41263, vol. 3, Clarkson to Dubois, I July
1793.
3. Fyfe, Anna Maria Falconbridge, p. 142: The records of
the London office of the Sierra Leone Company, which would have elucidated her claims, have not survived.
4. British Library, Add. MS 41263, Clarkson,
24 September 1793.
5. Ibid.
Clarkson 3 November 1793.
6. Ibid. Clarkson to Hartshorne, September 1793.
7.
The above quotations from Clarkson are found in Fyfe, Anna Maria Falconbridge, p. 156.
8. Fyfe, Anna Maria Falconbridge, p. 159: Macaulay however reported to Thornton
that "there is no document whatever of Falconbridge’s transactions." Journal, 29 August 1793. John Gray [sic] the government
accountant, had arrived in Freetown in 1792. He remained there until 1802 when, "after having devoted the best ten years of
my life" to the Sierra Leone Company, he resigned and moved to the rivers north of the colony to trade in slaves. Public Record
Office, CO 270/8, Council minutes, 27 January 1802, 8 December 1802.
9. Rag Fair was a second-hand clothes market in Houndsditch,
a poor part of London. Coleman, p. 168.
10. This Appendix is dropped from the
1802 edition.
11. Fyfe, Anna
Maria Falconbridge, p. 162: ‘Teach me to feel another’s woe/To hide the fault I see’: Alexander Pope,
Universal Prayer.
12. DuBois, who claimed 15 dependent relatives, eventually collected £5,320 from the Treasury in 1801 and another £5,000
from a committee of the House of Commons in 1807. In the meantime he was appointed Barrack Master at Tenterden in Kent in
1804 (at £150 a year) and subsequently Controller of Customs in Curaçao.
Fyfe, Anna Maria Falconbridge, pp. 168-9.
13. Deirdre Coleman
14. Christopher Fyfe
|